Deer Browse at the Leonard Preserve Sept 13, 2014
You can see the difference between fenced in area and that available to deer.
Hunting gives deer-damaged forests in state parks a shot at recovery
Phys.org, July 9, 2014
A research team led by Michael Jenkins, associate professor of forest ecology, found that a 17-year-long Indiana Department of Natural Resources policy of organizing hunts in state parks has successfully spurred the regrowth of native tree seedlings, herbs and wildflowers rendered scarce by browsing deer.
“We can’t put nature in a glass dome and think it’s going to regulate itself,” he said. “Because our actions have made the natural world the way it is, we have an obligation to practice stewardship to maintain ecological balance.”
Indiana state parks historically did not allow hunting. But by the 1990s, white-tailed deer populations in parks had swelled to such size that many species of native wildflowers such as trillium and lilies largely disappeared, replaced by wild ginger and exotic species such as garlic mustard and Japanese stiltgrass, plants not favored by deer. Oak and ash tree seedlings gave way to highly deer-resistant or unpalatable trees such as pawpaw.
In a long-term experimental demography study, excluding ungulates reversed invader’s explosive population growth rate and restored natives
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 111 no. 12, Mar 25, 2014
Susan Kalisz, p. 4501–4506.
In a long-term experimental demography study, excluding ungulates reversed invader’s explosive population growth rate and restored natives.
The study was long-term, over six years in a PA woodland with a deer population of 20-42 deer per km-sq (51-107 mi-sq), a population similar to some areas of Washtenaw County. There’s a lot of data and statistics in the report, and it shows that the garlic mustard population “explodes” (their “technical” term) where deer had access, but declines where deer were excluded. The ability of native plants to successfully compete with garlic mustard was dependent on the extent of deer browse. Deer never browsed on the garlic mustard, but selectively browsed the native plants.
For our natural areas to sustain the native plants that support a community of other wildlife, the PA study shows that the deer need to be managed at a level where the native flora can survive.
Excessive deer populations hurt native plant biodiversity
PhysOrg, March 11, 2014
To study the effect of rampant deer on trillium and garlic mustard populations, Kalisz and colleagues established multiple 196-square-meter plots in the forest. Half were fenced to exclude deer. Years of observation and hours of statistical analysis later, Kalisz and her colleagues have found that in plots where deer were excluded, the trillium population is increasing and the garlic mustard population is trending toward zero.
Excessive Deer Populations Hurt Native Plant Biodiversity, Pitt-Led Study Says
University of Pittsburgh News, March 10, 2014
The study, initiated in 2003 at the Trillium Trail Nature Reserve in Fox Chapel, Pa., concludes that an overpopulation of deer (density of deer in the United States is about four to 10 times what it was prior to European settlement of North America) is the primary reason garlic mustard is crowding out native plants, such as trillium, which are preferred food for wild deer.
Soil seed bank composition is important to the recovery of natural and semi-natural areas from disturbance and serves as a safeguard against environmental catastrophe. White-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) populations have increased dramatically in eastern North America over the past century and can have strong impacts on aboveground vegetation, but their impacts on seed bank dynamics are less known. To document the long-term effects of deer browsing on plant successional dynamics, we studied the impacts of deer on both aboveground vegetation and seed bank composition in plant communities following agricultural abandonment. In 2005, we established six 156 15 m fenced enclosures and paired open plots in recently fallowed agricultural fields near Ithaca, NY, USA. In late October of each of six years (2005–2010), we collected soil from each plot and conducted seed germination cycles in a greenhouse to document seed bank composition.
These data were compared to measurements of aboveground plant cover (2005–2008) and tree density (2005–2012). The impacts of deer browsing on aboveground vegetation were severe and immediate, resulting in significantly more bare soil, reduced plant biomass, reduced recruitment of woody species, and relatively fewer native species. These impacts persisted throughout the experiment. The impacts of browsing were even stronger on seed bank dynamics. Browsing resulted in significantly decreased overall species richness (but higher diversity), reduced seed bank abundance, relatively more short-lived species (annuals and biennials), and fewer native species. Both seed bank richness and the relative abundance of annuals/biennials were mirrored in the aboveground vegetation. Thus, deer browsing has long-term and potentially
reinforcing impacts on secondary succession, slowing succession by selectively consuming native perennials and woody species and favoring the persistence of short-lived, introduced species that continually recruit from an altered seed bank.
Where deer were present, patch sizes of ammonium availability, cover, and diversity were smaller compared to deer exclosures, whereas mean site-level effects were not significant. Within deer exclosures cover and solar radiation were more similar in patch size than were cover and nitrogen availability. Our results suggest that browsing ungulates affect spatial patterns of herb-layer cover and diversity through the excretion of nitrogenous wastes in small, discrete patches. Ungulate-excreted nitrogen deposition and herbivory were concentrated in the dormant season, allowing herb-layer plants a greater opportunity to benefit from nitrogen additions. Therefore, the impact of ungulates on nitrogen cycling in forest ecosystems varies with spatial scale and the seasonal timing of ungulate impacts. In this way, ungulates may function as a seasonally dependent link between fine-scale and landscape-level ecological processes.
The Science of Yellow Snow: White-tailed Deer may be Ruining their own Winter Havens
Michigan Tech News, June 2013
New research from wildlife ecologists at Michigan Technological University indicates that white-tailed deer may be making the soil in their preferred winter homes unfit to grow the very trees that protect them there.
Benefits to rare plants and highway safety from annual population reductions of a “native invader,” white-tailed deer, in a Chicago-area woodland
Richard M. Engeman, etal, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2013
We examined the benefits of culling deer at a Chicago-area woodland preserve by comparing browse rates on four endangered plant species from years before culling began with years with culling. We also examined deer–vehicle collision and traffic flow rates on area roads from years before culling began and years with culling to assess whether population reductions may have benefited road safety in the area. An economic analysis showed a cost savings during the cull years of US$0.6 million for reducing browsing to just these four monitored plant species and the reduction in deer–vehicle collisions.
Effects of climate change, deer and invasive species on forests
Lee E. Frelich, Director, The University of Minnesota Center for Forest Ecology, 2013
Global warming is about the effects of droughts, storms, fires, bugs, worms and deer on the forest.